I got a Supernote Manta about four weeks ago, and I wrote Supernote Manta First Impressions after using it for two days. Looking that post over, the only thing different is that I found out that you can use handwriting instead of typing in a lot of contexts by tapping the globe icon that shows up on the keyboard. This is marginally better than typing (which is very bad), so I still hope that it can get better in software updates. But, those impressions were about the visceral feel of the device, not how useful it is in practice.

After four weeks, I continue to be happy with Supernote as a replacement for paper journals. I have been using paper for my whole life, so I didn’t think this would be possible, and maybe it’s specific to me, but here are the reasons why I find it better than paper:

1. My ideal journal has a lot of pages. In 2024, my journal was almost 400 pages. It has gotten too big to carry. On the Supernote, I don’t have to think about this at all. I created a custom journal that has a page for each day and a lot more.
2. I like editing. I have come to rely on undo and cut/paste. I never had this with paper and didn’t consider this when moving to a tablet, but now I realize how important it is to me.
3. It’s also great for reading. The Supernote with the Kindle app is as good as my Kindle device, which I don’t use any more. So, in addition to not lugging my paper journal, I can also not take the Kindle (which was always in my daily carry).
4. It has all of my journals. I keep different kinds of journals. I have my daily, bullet-like journal, but I also have project specific ones and others (see Write While True Episode 21: Dedicated Journals). They are all slowly being migrated into the Supernote.

All of this would not matter at all if the writing on the device wasn’t comparable to paper. It is.

For me, the biggest downside (compared to paper) is that it is monochrome. I practice Two Color Journaling, where most writing is in black and important things are in red. I have been using other cues to highlight (symbols, boxes, the highlighter). It’s ok. I don’t think the new Remarkable (with color) would meet my other criteria, but it’s something to think about for the future. I guess I hope that color e-ink becomes ubiquitous and is available in a future Supernote.